Atheism as a refutation of classical theism is incontrovertible. If God is defined as something greater than life, then God doesnt exist. The most important thing is romantic love a man can have for one woman primarily is the highest felt meaning of the world. If God is defined as the origin of grace and salvation then God cant logically exist, because emotive response that creates the highest form of awareness in me is love for Sylvia Plath, not God.
Its a personal experience and so take what resonates.
https://youtu.be/M5n4mJkVivs
This is Quentin Smith's argument from Big Bang cosmology for atheism, which is brilliant logic that i adapted for the syllogism of life as being important.
However i reject his premise that whats most important is whats most important for life as a whole, because that's fundamentally unknowable and impractical for any practical form of ethic.
All life is equal to itself and i respect my own life and let other life be what it is as my life unfolds respectfully. Whats most important for life as a whole is unknowable, because that would imply a consciousness without a body and a brain, that Quentin Smith agreed is impossible.
If life has a purpose for something other than just survival, would be to serve a non personal mechanism that has no life. (Hence the atheistic deduction.) If life has a purpose for something other than itself then God cant logically exist.
@Charles Bell
But love is the thing that gives everything else form. When love is perfect in the bottom like a solid floor then there's no place to get too. Everything has value just because it exists, not because of what it can do for me. Thats why purpose of life is a contradiction. Life either has value for its own sake, or nothing has value at all. The implication is that all life has equal value, but the only life that can logically have immediate value in relationship to life as a whole can only be mine, otherwise life has no context and would be flat and life couldn't logically sustain itself if each life form didnt have its own primary consciousness.
My felt meaning of the world that is best for the world for me is my love for Sylvia Plath. Even with her i can only respect myself first because her life, though in closest relevance to my own, is the only ethical bridge that allows me to be whats best for everyone else.
God cant be that for me. His purpose intent would imply my life had no value. So God big G cant exist, logically.
This is some of that conversation
No comments:
Post a Comment